Showing posts with label Trades. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Trades. Show all posts

Tuesday, July 8, 2008

The Elton Brand mirage (?)I

If the Sixers were able to sign Elton Brand, I can't even begin to describe how happy I'd be. He's a great player, plus he fits the Sixers need for a strong low-post presence.

I was in the middle of writing that despite how excited I'd be and the flurry of articles today about the possibility, I seriously doubted that the Sixers were in real contention for his services. Then I went to ESPN.com to try and find links to the articles that I'd read on the topic earlier today, and I came across this article:
NBA front-office sources told ESPN.com on Tuesday that Brand has informed the Sixers that he will accept a five-year deal worth an estimated $82 million and spurn what was presumed to be a slam-dunk return to the Los Angeles Clippers to hook up with Clipper-to-be Baron Davis.
I mean...wow. Just, wow.

(I'm speechless)

(As a side note, all the articles from earlier in the day have been replaced by updated versions that include this more recent information, so no links to them. Sorry.)

As the articles from earlier today hinted (and this most recent article stated), the Sixers are creating more room under the salary cap to make this signing possible by trading Rodney Carney, Calvin Booth, and a first round pick to the Timberwolves for a second round pick and/or a part of a trade exception (depending on which article you read-- the trade has only been agreed to in principle at this point). It seems odd to trade away players for basically nothing, but I wasn't too bothered by the trade because I haven't been very impressed by Carney and hopefully the Sixers first round pick won't be a good one in coming years. If this trade actually makes it possible for the Sixers to sign Brand, I'll be one happy camper.

If I'm a Clippers fan, then I'm definitely one unhappy camper. And I'd probably feel a little used. After all, when Brand opted out of the last year of his contract, he talked about how he planned on resigning with the Clippers and was opting out in part to give the Clippers more payroll flexibility so they could get him some better support. So what happens? The Clippers go out and reach an agreement in principle with Baron Davis, using some of the money that could have been used for Brand, and Brand (apparently) agrees to sign with another team for less than the Clippers could have originally offered him (but more than the current offer). And less than the Warriors are offering. Huh.

(If you're keeping track, the reported offers are: Sixers, 5 years, $82 milliion; Clippers, 5 years, $75 million; Warriors, 5 years, $90 million.)

I guess we'll find out what's really going on tomorrow. And in the mean time, for a well-balanced, let's-not-get-all-hysterical-quite-yet take on the situation from the perspective of a Clippers fan, you can go here. For a Sixers fan, this paragraph is probably the key insight:

Look, we don't have any more information from Elton today than we did last Monday night. It's a little nerve-wracking, I'll grant you that. But we suspected most of this would happen from the start, didn't we? We suspected Philly would try to get in the game. We suspected (after the first day or so), that Elton would take his time and listen to everyone, if only to do his due diligence. Did Philly shed contracts in order to squeeze out a bigger offer to EB because of 'smoke signals coming from Brand's teepee' as John Hollinger so politically incorrectly put it? Maybe, maybe not. Remember, they've got their sights set on Josh Smith too, and a bigger offer there is just as relevant as a bigger offer to Brand. They'll offer the money to Brand first for two reasons - one, he's better. But more importantly, he's unrestricted and can answer with a simple 'yes' or 'no'. With Smith, if they make the offer and he accepts it, Atlanta has 7 days to match, which could tie up Philly's money for 7 days. So an offer to Smith precludes an offer to Brand. So you go after Brand first, whether or not it's a long shot.

The idea that the Sixers have a more exciting team for Brand to join just doesn't ring true. Andre Miller? EB's been there and done that, and even if he thought Andre was a great piece of the puzzle there, this is pretty clearly his last season in Philly. So I hardly see Miller as a big draw. Does Elton want to get into the Eastern Conference where he can make the all star team and the playoffs without breaking a sweat? Maybe. But I fail to see the Sixers as having a more promising future than the Clippers with Baron Davis.

(I disagree that the Clippers have a brighter future than the Sixers, but everyone thinks a little more highly of their own team's future)

Tuesday, May 20, 2008

The second pick in the draft

The NBA Draft lottery was held tonight, and the Chicago Bulls ended up with the number one pick. The Miami Heat ended up with the second pick. From all accounts, this year's draft is dominated by power forward Michael Beasley (from Kansas State) and point guard Derrick Rose (from Memphis). So the big guessing game over the next month will be which of these two players Chicago will choose.

My question is: why settle for one?

The Miami Heat are looking to get back into contention quickly. With Dwayne Wade on the roster, they really can't afford to take a long-view (he becomes a free agent in 2010, and presumably he won't resign if they aren't competitive at that point). Either Rose or Beasley (or both) might become franchise players a few years down the road, but will they be game changers next year or the year after? Hard to say.

With that as the backdrop, what are the Heat's needs? Admittedly, I don't watch that many of their games, but I think it's safe to say that Wade, Marion, and Haslem form a solid shooting guard/small-forward/power-forward trifecta. Miami needs a quality center and point guard.

What about the Bulls? Coming into this season, many people (including myself) expected them to compete for the Eastern Conference championship. After this (disappointing) season, the sense I get from reading Blog-a-Bull is that Chicago fans would be willing to take a step backwards next season in order to create a "higher ceiling" for the team going forward. At the same time, the Bulls do have a number of solid players on their roster, even if they don't have a superstar. For big men, they have Drew Gooden, Tyrus Thomas, and Joakim Noah. Gooden has already proven that he can be an important contributor on a finals-worthy team (Cleveland, last season), Thomas is still viewed as having tremendous potential, and Noah had a very solid rookie season. At guard, the Bulls rotation is headed by Kirk Hinrich, Ben Gordon, and Larry Hughes.

I think the Bulls should offer Gooden, Hinrich, and either Hughes or Thomas to the Heat for the second pick in the draft. The Bulls most likely get worse next year as Rose and Beasley both struggle as rookies, but they'll have a very talented nucleus of Rose, Gordon, Luol Deng, Beasley, and Noah. And they'll all be young with a chance to grow together.

Would the Heat make this trade? It depends. In theory, it would meet their needs for a point guard and center that could immediately step in and help them be competitive. However, while he's been highly regarded in the past and played on Team USA, Hinrich had a very disappointing season this past year (the administrator at Blog-a-Bull considers him to be average at best). Gooden, for his part, is more of a power forward than a center, although I don't think there are many centers in the NBA at the moment who he can't guard. If the Bulls sweeten the pot by adding Thomas or Hughes (or both, or any other player the Heat want that isn't part of the nucleus I mention above), then I'd think the Heat would at least need to think about it. But maybe my valuation of the players on the Bulls is still too influenced by last season rather than the season that actually just happened.

Friday, December 21, 2007

365 days later (or so)

Apparently, the one year anniversary of the Iverson trade was the signal for the pundits to come out of the woodwork and make snide comments about the Sixers. Two recent comments in particular rankled me a bit because they seemed to reflect a real lack of research.

First, over at ESPN.com, Marc Stein slammed what the Sixers got in return for Iverson. What made it even more bizarre to me was that he recognized that the Nuggets haven't had an amazing record with Iverson, but still talked as if the Nuggets had robbed the Sixers.

Then, over at CNNSI.com, Jack McMallum describes the Sixers as a team "playing over its head" in his Christmas list column.

It seems to me that both comments reflect the same basic bias-- that Iverson is a superstar and that the Sixers must be terrible and must have gotten fleeced in the trade because they didn't get a superstar in return. It seems to me that the way to evaluate a trade is to see which team got better as a result of the trade, not comparing the "names" that each team got in the trade. And on that basis, I think its pretty clear that the Sixers at least broke even (and maybe even got the better end of the trade).

Let's take a look at how the trade impacted the performance of both teams.

First, the Sixers. In the 2005-06 season with Iverson, the Sixers were 38-44 (.463). In 2006-07 after the Iverson trade (he was suspended before the trade, so those games aren't particularly informative), the Sixers were 30-29. After Iverson was traded and after Webber was bought out (two weeks later), the Sixers went 26-21. This season through 25 games the Sixers were 10-15 (.400). All told, the Sixers are 40-44 (.476) since the Iverson trade (or 36-36 (.500) since getting rid of both Iverson and Webber).

Next, the Nuggets. In the 2005-06 season, the Nuggets were 44-38 (.537). In 2006-07, before the trade, the Nuggets were 14-9 (.609). The trade happened one game into Carmelo Anthony's 15 game suspension. Excluding those 14 games (in which the Nuggets went 6-8), the Nuggets went 25-20 (.556) after the Iverson trade. This season through 25 games the Nuggets were 15-10 (.600). All told, the Nuggets are 40-30 (.571) since the Iverson trade (excluding the games for which Carmelo was suspended).

To recap: Before the trade, the Sixers were a slightly below average team (.463). After the trade, the Sixers have been a slightly below average team (.476). Before the trade, the Nuggets were an above average, but not great, team (.552). After the trade, the Nuggets have been an above average, but not great, team (.571).

Once you account for the fact that the Nuggets supporting cast has also improved, notably Marcus Camby has been healthy and was named Defensive Player of the Year last season, and the salary cap space that the Sixers will gain after this season as a result of the trade, then I don't see how you can say the Nuggets made out better than the Sixers in this deal. Even without accounting for these things, I still don't see how the Sixers got fleeced.

I also don't see how the Sixers can still be considered to be playing over their heads after playing at this level for the equivalent of an entire season. But I'm not holding my breath for the pundits to actually notice.

Thursday, October 25, 2007

Ex-Celtics swapped just for fun

Well, I'm sure it wasn't just for fun, but I'm still not sure what advantage both teams were looking for in the deal.

In case you haven't heard (and if you don't check basketball related websites religiously like I do, you probably haven't), the Miami Heat traded Ex-Celtic Antoine Walker, Michael Doleac, and some potato chips (potato chips = Wayne Simien and a conditional first round draft pick) to the Minnesota Timberwolves for Mark Blount and Ricky Davis.

When I first heard about the trade, my initial thought was that Kevin McHale was trying get as many former Celtics on his roster as he possibly could. Sort of like a scavenger hunt, but with real NBA players as the items you were supposed to collect.

Then I realized that both Ricky Davis and Mark Blount were also ex-Celtics, so McHale was actually lowering his number of former Celtics by making this trade. At this point, I decided it'd be impossible to figure out what the point of this trade was for either team (which doesn't mean I won't try).

As near as I can tell, this trade was done entirely for personality reasons. It's been all over the (basketball) news the last few days that Riley was unhappy with Walker for not being in condition to start training camp (I guess Shaq has a special dispensation to play his way into shape over the course of the season. Role players--and that's what Walker is these days--don't get that same luxury.) There were also reports earlier this summer (after the big trade for Garnett) that Al Jefferson hadn't really gotten along with Blount when they'd been in Boston together. If true (I have no idea), that would explain Minnesota's desire to make the trade.

In terms of playing ability, Michael Doleac and Mark Blount are basically the same player, and I don't buy the argument that Ricky Davis is a better offensive player than Walker--they're both high volume, low percentage shooters.

[brief pause as I go and actually look up Walker's and Davis' stats from last year...]

Well, it turns out Davis is a better offensive player, but not by that much. Last year Walker shot 39.5% from the filed, taking .37 shots/minute. Davis shot 46.3% from the field, taking .36 shots/minute. I was going to say that I thought Minnesota got both the better players and the better contracts (Walker's contract goes for two more years, but Blount's goes for three more years), but I guess I'll just need to say that Minnesota got the better contracts.

I guess for the first few weeks while Wade is out Davis will be an important player for the Heat, but I'm not sure I see him playing a major role once Wade returns. (And if Wade doesn't return, it really doesn't matter who the Heat have on their roster.) He can play pretty good perimeter defense, so maybe they can play him at the small forward position and have him guard the better perimeter players so Wade can rest on the defensive end. Still, I don't see this trade really doing much for the Heat's chances this year.

I'm also unclear what role Walker will have with the Timberwolves. Jefferson is clearly the centerpiece of the revamped team, and he and Walker both play the power forward spot. The Wolves could go small and play Jefferson at the center position, but if they were going to do that then I'd think they'd want Craig Smith to play the power forward position (a defensive and rebounding presence to complement Jefferson's offensive presence). The article I linked to indicated that McHale might have some other trades in the works, so my best guess is that Walker's stay in Minnesota will be a brief one.


And yes, I know that this trade doesn't impact the Sixers in any way.

Friday, September 21, 2007

It's getting to be that time of year again

In his column at ESPN.com today, Marc Stein gives his evaluation of the off-season moves made by each Eastern Conference team. He likes the Sixers pick-up of Reggie Evans, but other than that gives the Sixers low marks--primarily on the basis of the lack of moves made this summer. I'm not in agreement with all of his evaluations (for instance, I think Orlando took a step backwards this summer), but his column is a clear sign that "season preview" season is just around the corner. Training camps start in two weeks, and things around here will probably pick up a bit once that happens. I can't wait!

Tuesday, September 18, 2007

Reggie Evans, Philadelphia. Philadelphia, Reggie Evans.

What do I think of the Sixers' acquisition of Reggie Evans (and the rights to Rickey Sanchez) from the Denver Nuggets in return for Steven Hunter and Bobby Jones? I can tell tell you in three short words: I like it. Want a few more words? I like it a lot!

The Sixers really needed a power forward who could provide rebounding and solid interior defense, and Reggie Evans fits the bill. As the Philadelphia Inquirer put it:
The 6-foot-8, 245-pound Evans will give the Sixers some much-needed toughness in the interior. Last season, he led the NBA in rebounds per 48 minutes (19.7). Evans averaged 7.0 rebounds in 17.1 minutes per game.
Even more impressive, Reggie Evans had the best rebound rate in the NBA in 2004-05 (23.9%), 2005-06 (21.4%), and 2006-07 (23.0%). Also, he isn't a rebounder on just one side of the ball. He gets both offensive and defensive rebounds, averaging 5.5 offensive rebounds and 10.8 defensive rebounds per 40 minutes.

As for the non-rebounding portion of his defense, I recall him being a very physical defender (although not necessarily a very good defender). His average of 5.1 fouls per 40 minutes supports this observation about his defense. It also helps explain why he has been traditionally overlooked--coaches are reluctant to keep him on the floor because he gets into foul trouble (and because coaches generally don't like to play non-scorers, despite all the talk about the importance of defense). I say leave him on the floor until he fouls out. If we can get 30 minutes a night out of him as our starting power forward and get his rebound production for that amount of time, then I think accepting a few extra fouls as the price for his production is a good trade. Yes, I'd prefer fewer fouls, but you take players as they are, not as you want them to be!

For what it's worth, Win Score metrics also indicate this trade was a steal for the Sixers. The numbers available show that both Steven Hunter and Bobby Jones were below average players last season. Reggie Evans, on the other hand, was well above average with a WP48 of .300 (.100 is average for all NBA players). The proof is in the pudding, but for now I'm very enthusiastic about this trade for the Sixers. Now we just need to hope that the Sixers' coaches are smart enough to take advantage of the rebounding machine they've been given.

Tuesday, September 11, 2007

The Sixers make a move

I'm still on the road, but I caught this tidbit:

Steven Hunter and Bobby Jones to Denver for Reggie Evans and Ricky Sanchez. Plus, the Sixers signed Calvin Booth.

I'll comment on the trade once I get to Anchorage.

Thursday, August 30, 2007

Can the Kobe fun start again now?

In his article at ESPN.com today, Chris Sheridan drops this little nugget at the end:
Bryant, by the way, said he "hadn't really had a chance to speak to" Los Angeles Lakers general manager Mitch Kupchak, who was in attendance Wednesday night.
Drama! Excitement! Intrigue!

Considering the blow-out games that have occurred at the Tournament of the Americas (see here for a description of Team USA's latest rout, led by a perfect first half from Lebron James), I'm almost excited for the Kobe-circus to resume....

Wednesday, August 8, 2007

O'Neal-Bryant: An addendum

Two quick points to make as an addendum to my previous post about the possibility of the Lakers getting Jermaine O'Neal:

1. Since I think the Lakers should be willing to trade Andrew Bynum to get Jermaine O'Neal, do I also think they should have been willing to trade him to get Jason Kidd? Yes, absolutely. The idea that the Lakers gave up getting Jason Kidd because they didn't want to give up Bynum is really hard for me to fathom, and I'm not as big a fan of Jason Kidd as most people. I will say that Kidd's age scares me a little--I keep expecting his game to take a sharp decline, but it hasn't happened yet. However, while I readily concede that Kidd is a better player than Jermaine O'Neal, I'm not sure that he would improve the Lakers as much as O'Neal would. Why? First, I think the Lakers major problem last year was interior defense. As good of a perimeter defender as Kidd is, I don't really see how his presence helps the Lakers with their major defensive problems. Second, I think some of Kidd's talents would be wasted on the Lakers because of the triangle offense. In the triangle, the point guard often initiates the offense by passing the ball into a stationary player at the high post and then moves away. I'm not sure you need a point guard with Kidd's tremendous play-making ability and court vision to initiate the offense. Obviously, the Lakers would have been more potent in the open floor with three players who could lead the break (Kidd, Kobe, Odom; and possibly Luke Walton). I'm also sure Phil Jackson would have tweaked the triangle offense to take advantage of Kidd's abilities, but I still think some of Kidd's talents would have been wasted, and his one shortcoming (poor outside shooting) would have been more apparent than it normally is when he's creating for other people. Still, the Lakers clearly should have been willing to give up Andrew Bynum to get Jason Kidd.

2. Would a trade for Jermaine O'Neal that didn't involve Lamar Odom even be feasible under NBA rules? According to the ESPN trade machine (and the proposed trade mentioned in the update to yesterday's post), the answer is "Yes." The first trade I tried (Kwame Brown, Vladimir Radmanovic, and Andrew Bynum for O'Neal) worked fine. However, it's not at all clear that the Pacers would be interested in the available players other than Bynum, and if you eliminate Brown and Radmanovic from the trade equation then it becomes hard to find enough available salary to match up with O'Neal's $19.7 million cap number. So what's the verdict? Feasible? Yes. Likely? No, but certainly doable if the Lakers are willing to throw in cash and draft picks.

Friday, August 3, 2007

The Return of Celtic Pride

I know I'm a bit late to the party on this one, but I just wanted to give my thoughts on the Kevin Garnett-to-Boston trade that happened this week. I think I can sum it up in just a few words: I like it! And I actually like it for both teams.

First, the details:
Boston sent the Minnesota Timberwolves forwards Al Jefferson, Ryan Gomes and Gerald Green, guard Sebastian Telfair and center Theo Ratliff, two first-round draft picks and cash considerations. Besides Ratliff, 34, the other four are 22 or younger.

...

The Timberwolves get the Celtics' first-round pick in 2009, unless it is among the top three, and a return of Minnesota's conditional first-round draft pick obtained in January 2006 when they sent Ricky Davis to the Timberwolves for Wally Szczerbiak.

From Boston's end, the attraction of the trade is a no-brainer: You get KG! He's one of the top five players in the league. For my money, if I needed a player for just this upcoming season, the only player in the league I would definitely take over KG would be Tim Duncan. There are a few other players I would need to really think about, but Duncan's the only one I would definitely put ahead of him. By pairing KG with Paul Pierce and Ray Allen, the Celtics now have three players who complement each other and are all in their primes. Before, the Celtics were a bit mismatched--last year they had Pierce and a bunch of still-developing players, and even the addition of Ray Allen didn't really change that equation that much. They weren't good enough to contend now, and it wasn't clear that the veterans would still be good when the youngsters had finally developed. Now, the Celtics have a clear identity--they're trying to win now, and they have the veteran core to make that possible. I don't have any doubt that KG, Allen, and Pierce will all be Eastern Conference all-stars this season.

The one potential problem with the trade is that Boston's cupboard behind KAP (as they Big 3 will now be abbreviated) is now looking quite bare. KAP will be able to get the Celtics to the playoffs, but the real success of the season is going to depend on the talent that Danny Ainge is going to be able to put around them. The starting line-up is rounded out with Kendrick Perkins and Rajon Rondo, a bit off a drop-off in talent from the other three starters. I think Perkins and Rondo will do fine (Perkins will supply defense and rebounding, Rondo will provide energy), but they are still a bit young. The drop-off in talent once you get to the bench is even more severe. I'm a big fan of Tony Allen (assuming he fully recovers from his injury), but after him I'm not sure that anyone on the bench is really going to contribute much (Leon Powe? Brian Scalabrine?). The absence of an NBA ready back-up point guard is a particularly bad situation.

The most in-depth analysis I've seen about the importance of surrounding KAP with talent for a successful season can be found in this article at the Wages of Wins. The basic gist of the article is that KAP are good for 40 wins by themselves (assuming 35 minutes a game, playing as well as they did last season). If they get the NBA average amount of support from the rest of the team, the Celtics will win around 50 games. If they get as little support as the Nets' Big 3 get (the worst in the league), then they'll only win around 45 games. Based on the Celtics current roster, 45 wins looks a lot more likely, so hopefully Ainge will be able to pick up some more talent before the season starts. Personally, I think the Celtics should make sure to play KAP between 30-35 minutes a game to make sure they get enough rest over the course of the season. 45 wins will be plenty to make the playoffs. Then the Celtics can ride their horses for 40+ minutes a night in the playoffs a make a real run for the NBA Finals.

From the Timberwolves' perspective, this trade was all about the future. Even with KG, the Timberwolves hadn't made the playoffs in two years, and they really didn't have any good way to obtain the talent needed to surround him. The Timberwolves will be one of the worst teams in the league this year, but now they have a handful of young talents who might develop into future stars. Getting back their first round pick is a big deal because, based on how bad they'll be this year, that pick could end up being the top pick in next year's NBA draft.

I'm a huge fan of Al Jefferson. I think he was definitely going to be an all-star in the Eastern Conference this year. The Western Conference is loaded with power forwards so Jefferson will not be in the top tier of power forwards in the conference this year, but in two years I think there's a very good chance he'll have played his way onto that all-star team. Including "Big Al," the young talent on the Timberwolves' roster includes Randy Foye, Gerald Green, Corey Brewer, Rashad McCants, Craig Smith, Chris Richards (assuming he signs), and Sebastian Telfair (all of whom have been in the NBA three years or less). There's definitely a bit of duplication in skills among these players (particularly at the shooting guard and small forward position), so it'll be interesting to see how it all shakes out.

I haven't seen the holdover Timberwolves play so I don't have any opinions on them (Foye, Smith, McCants), but I do think the players who just arrive from Boston have bright futures. The one player in the bunch who I think has gotten a bad rap is Sebastian Telfair. He's had some off-court issues, but mostly he's been criticized for his on-court play which puzzles me a little bit. From watching him play, I think he plays the way a point-guard should--he moves the ball and gets his teammates involved. His passes don't necessarily lead to assists, but they keep the offense flowing (as opposed to Delonte West, for instance, who people seem to really like, but who tends to pound the ball forever when he's playing the point). His WP48 is terrible (-0.075), but I think he's doing something right--as you can see on this chart, last season the plus/minus of every Celtic except Jefferson and Green was better with him on the court than when he was not on the court. The only other Celtics who could make that claim were Paul Pierce and Rajon Rondo!

So all in all: Good trade for the Celtics because it gives them a legitimate chance to contend for the Eastern Conference title right now, and good trade for the Timberwolves because they weren't going anywhere with KG and this trade gives them a chance to build around young, developing talent.

The only bad news is that this just creates another Eastern Conference team that is clearly superior to the Sixers (who have neither competitive veteran talent nor substantial young talent)...

Friday, July 13, 2007

Feels like a quiet day

Not much happening on the free agency front to report. I've been skimming various NBA related websites all day, and there just doesn't seem to be that much to talk about--certainly not Sixers related.

But if you feel the need to read something, there's been some talk about Memphis' new look and the somewhat puzzling trade made by the Spurs--a current NBA player and the rights to the best player in Europe (Luis Scola) for a European player who says he is definitely going back to Europe, a second round pick, and cash.

At that discount rate, maybe the Sixers could pick up Tim Duncan for Samuel Dalembert and a first round pick...

Friday, July 6, 2007

Yi-ppee!

I was all set to write a post today about how the Sixers should make an offer for Yi Jianlian since his agent's comments indicate a strong lack of desire on his part to play for Milwaukee. Then I read this article a few minutes ago in which Larry Harris (the Bucks GM) says that they have no interest in trading Yi.

Oh well.

You know what? The Sixers should still make an offer. The worst that can happen is that Milwaukee says no. I doubt we can get him, but it's worth a try.

Thursday, July 5, 2007

High profile offers for Greg Oden

Via TrueHoop, we get directed to this article by Jason Quick in the Oregonian from this past Sunday. In it, Quick describes some of the offers that Kevin Pritchard (the Trailblazer's GM) received for the number one pick (i.e. Greg Oden) in this past draft, and apparently some of the offers were quite substantial:
  • From an Eastern conference team: A five-time All-Star and this year's lottery pick in exchange for the No. 1 pick and the Blazers' 2008 first-round pick.
  • A team within the Blazers division proposed a trade involving a future Hall of Famer and a standout rookie for the Blazers' No. 1 pick.
  • From a "Western conference power": The general manager wanted the Blazers' No. 1 pick. And he was willing to offer a player that will be a first-ballot Hall of Famer.
Quick leaves the details on these proposed trades a bit thin, most likely to protect his sources, but I think it isn't too hard to figure out the identities of the involved parties, particularly in the first two trade scenarios.

In the first trade offer, I think it's clear that the offer was Paul Pierce and the Celtic's lottery pick (5th overall). There are only six Eastern conference teams that were in the lottery this year (Atlanta- twice, Milwaukee, Boston, Charlotte, Chicago- from New York, and Philadelphia), and Paul Pierce is the only five-time all-star on any of these rosters.

In the second trade offer, I think the offer must have been Kevin Garnett and Randy Foye. The teams in the Blazer's division are Utah, Denver, Minnesota, and Seattle. Of those teams, only Denver (Iverson) and Minnesota (Garnett) have players that I would consider certain Hall of Famers at this stage of their careers, and of those two teams only Minnesota had a standout rookie this past season.

The third trade offer I think is a bit trickier. Over at TrueHoop, Henry Abbot identifies San Antonio, Phoenix, and Dallas as the Western conference powers, eliminates Nowitzki from consideration as not a certain first-ballot Hall of Famer, eliminates Nash because the Suns attack only works with him running it, and comes to the conclusion that the Spurs offered Tim Duncan for the right to pick Greg Oden. I'm not sure I agree.

First, I find it hard to believe that the Spurs would offer Tim Duncan in a trade under any circumstances. He is, in my opinion, currently the best player in the NBA. His teams just win. And the Spurs have a very real chance to win another 2-3 NBA titles before Duncan retires. Why make a trade to get someone who may or may not one day be as good as Duncan is right now? I don't think it makes much sense, especially since the Spurs are already stockpiling talent (drafting players who continue playing overseas) for the day when Duncan is no longer the dominant force in the NBA. In addition, the same article by Quick mentions Popovich having a conversation with Pritchard, apparently before this third trade offer was made, in which Popovich talked about Pritchard having the chance to put together a twin-towers tandem even better than Duncan and David Robinson had been. I highly doubt he would have given such fulsome praise to Oden and LaMarcus Aldridge just before trying to get Pritchard to trade Oden.

If not Duncan, then who? I really don't know, but I think Henry Abbott might have read "Western conference power" too restrictively. In my mind, the two current first ballot Hall of Famers playing in the Western conference are Tim Duncan and Kobe Bryant. While they aren't currently a powerhouse, the Lakers are still a playoff team and they are certainly a traditional Western conference power. Especially considering all the Kobe Bryant fireworks that have gone on this summer, I think it's more likely that the mystery general manager was Mitch Kupchak (the Laker's GM) rather than RC Buford (the Spur's GM). But I guess we'll never really know.

Saturday, June 30, 2007

Zach Randolph- Part II

The Sixers never made a move for him, but the New York Knicks did--and it seems like Portland wanted to do the deal for the reasons discussed in my previous Zach Randolph post. The trade was Steve Francis and Channing Frye for Randolph, Dan Dickau, and Fred Jones.

From Portland's perspective, the benefits are pretty straight-forward: more playing time for their young frontcourt tandem and future salary cap relief. According to sources cited by ESPN, Portland is planning to buy-out Francis' contract and make him a free agent this summer. Portland also gets Channing Frye who had a stellar rookie season, even if he did have a bit of a sophomore slump this past season. I'm not sure how he fits into Portland's future, but at the very least he gives them a nice bargaining chip for a future trade.

As for New York's end of the trade, I'm cautiously optimistic that it can work for them. As a Sixer's fan this makes me unhappy, but I guess they've been suffering for awhile. Best case scenario, the Knicks can run an offense similar to the old Spurs offense with Duncan and Robinson. Post the ball on one side of the floor, and then, if nothing is open, swing the ball and immediately post the other player on the opposite block. Having two legitimate post players is a huge boon to a team because it's really hard to double the second post man. To mix things up, the Knicks can also run foul-line pick-and-pops using Randolph (the way the Spurs used to run them with Robinson) since he has pretty good touch from out there (at least, that's my recollection--I haven't actually seen him play recently). However, the Spurs analogy only goes so far since Duncan and Robinson were also two of the best defenders and rebounders in the NBA. Randolph can certainly rebound, but I don't think either he or Curry have ever been confused with good defenders.

The one thing I'm not sure about from the Knicks end is where does this leave David Lee? He played great last year for them, but with Randolph and Curry taking the bulk of the minutes at the four and five positions, I'm not sure where he's going to find the playing time this season. I guess we'll need to wait and see.

Wednesday, June 27, 2007

Zach Randolph

The assumption on the part of most Trailblazer fans seems to be that if they select Greg Oden (as expected), then Zach Randolph will become available. Moving out Randolph would both clear up playing time for LaMarcus Aldridge and prevent Randolph from "poisoning" the young players, or so the reasoning goes.

Whatever his flaws, Randolph can definitely fill up the stat sheet (per game averages of 23.6 points, 10.1 rebounds this past season), and the 76'ers could definitely use a low-post scoring threat. Any chance that the Sixers could get him without giving up any of their key players (Igoudala, Miller, Dalembert, Korver)? Unfortunately, it doesn't seem likely.

Playing around on the ESPN Trade Machine, you can put together a package that works (Randolph for a "starting line-up" of back-up players: Steven Hunter, Shavlik Randolph, Rodney Carney, Willie Green, and Kevin Ollie), but it seems unlikely that Portland would be interested in our spare parts. On the other hand, it all depends on how badly Portland wants to ship out Randolph. By trading Randolph, the Blazers would get some quicker salary relief, as only Willie Green's contract has as much time remaining (5 years) as Randolph's contract.

Another possibility would be for the Sixers to draft an NBA ready small forward (Jeff Green and Al Thornton are two players who fit the bill and whom the Sixers are supposedly interested in already), making Korver available as part of the package. With the Trailblazers likely to be centered on Gred Oden for the next decade, they might find real value in having a sharpshooter like Korver on their roster (plus, Oden would be able to cover for Korver's defensive deficiencies).

I have zero reason to believe that something like this is on anyone's radar screen. Nor, as I said, do I think it likely that Portland would be that interested. On the other hand, I can dream, can't I?